Copied from the Globe and Mail
Internet hate case delayed
as rights lawyer suspended

Ousting of outspoken commission attorney
draws comparison to Alliance party tactics


BY COLIN FREEZE
INVESTIGATIONS UNIT


The case against a B.C. man ac-
cused of using the Internet to incite
hatred is unraveling in the wake of
The Canadian Human Rights Com-
mission's suspension of a lawyer
who publicly Criticized the agency.
    John Micka was scheduled to ap
pear before a tribunal next week to
answer a complaint against his
Web site,which he argues is "anti
pedophile" and "pro-heterosexual,"
but not antigay.

    But the case has been delayed
until June, because lead lawyer
Eddie Taylor was told to leave his
workplace on Monday.
    Citing the ouster, one expert wit
ness said yesterday he may no
longer testify.
    "This business about his being
suspended seems outrageous to
me," said Gary Prideaux, a linguist
whose expertise in analyzing im
plicit meanings was used in a simi
lar complaint against Holocaust
denier Ernst Zundel.
    Dr. Prideaux said that because he
holds Mr. Taylor in high regard, he
would be "very reluctant" to testify
in the case against Mr. Micka,
should it be handed off to another, commission lawyer.
    "I'm really astounded that the
hurnan-rights commission is using
the same tactics that a certain polit-
ical party is using to deal with its
dissenters," Dr. Prideaux said,

drawing a comparison to the
Canadian Alliance.
    In an interview that was published Saturday in The Globe and Mail, Mr. Tavlor criticized his organization's leadership and direction and said the body had lost its moral authority.
    Many of his criticisms were echoed in an internal report work, a work place assessrnent that found the commissions stall also had harsh criticisms.

'Throwing him out of the
office and escorting him
out of the building in that
way seems to us to be
extremely inappropriate.'

    The tribunal granted a delay in the case after the commission's general counsel requested it in a letter on Monday. "Due to unforeseeable circumstances, Mr. Taylor is no longer available," he wrote.
    Earlier that same day, Mr. Taylor was marched Out of his workplace of 10 years and informed he was under investigation for both his conduct and his published com-
ments

    Many complaints of harassment and discrimination will be affected by the suspension, said Joel Richler,
a lawyer who is now looking into filing a lawsuit on Mr. Taylor's behalf.
    "He's got a large number of cases on his plate—his number to me was about 23 or 24—more than anybody else as far as I'm aware," Mr. Richler said.
    " Throwing him out of the office and escorting him out of the building in that way seems to us to be extremely inappropriate and detrimental to the public interest."
    Mr. Richler argues the matter has less to do with the outspoken lawyer's conduct than his public statements, though commission executives have said the opposite.
    Mr. Micka said he finds the suspension curious. "It would be ironical if Mr. Taylor's inability to be available is related to his exercising his Freedom of Speech," he wrote in an e-mail sent to the tribunal.
    Canadian Alliance member Rahim Jaffer raised the suspension in the House of Commons yesterday, describing it as the only action the commission has taken since the report.
    Justice Minister Anne McLellan responded by commending the commission for the workplace study, adding she is confident managers will address concerns.
    The stress of recent days may have taken a toll on Mr. Taylor, who was in the emergency department of the Ottawa Civic Hospital last night after complaining of chest pains. "He's doing fine," said a nurse, addling he was awaiting the results of bloodwork



Investigations@globeandmail.ca